THE HERITAGE COLLECTION
Authenticity is their nourishment.
Neapolitan-Style Sourdough Pizza, Just the Way I Remember It
Makes 3 pizzas (about 270 g dough each)
Airy • Blistered • Tomato-Rich • Long-Fermented
An airy, long-fermented sourdough pizza with a dramatically puffed crust, simply topped with ripe tomatoes, creamy ricotta, fresh basil, and olive oil.
This recipe is 100% plant-based.
Pizza is one of those foods that seems so familiar that we forget it has a story.
Long before pizza became what we recognize today, people throughout the Mediterranean were eating flatbreads topped with simple ingredients. But Naples became the place where modern pizza truly found its identity. By the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the city’s working people were eating inexpensive flatbreads topped with things like tomatoes, garlic, oil, and eventually cheese — simple food made from what was available, eaten because it was delicious, practical, and affordable.
And then there is the famous Margherita.
Tradition tells us that in 1889, during a visit to Naples by Queen Margherita of Savoy, pizzaiolo Raffaele Esposito prepared a pizza topped with tomato, mozzarella, and basil — red, white, and green, the colors of the Italian flag — and named it Pizza Margherita in her honor. Food historians have debated the details of that story, but I almost don’t mind. What has endured is the pizza itself: tomato, mozzarella, basil, dough. Nothing unnecessary. And perhaps that simplicity tells us more about Italian cooking than the legend ever could.
I came to understand that kind of simplicity when I spent time in Italy.
I studied in Bologna while earning my homeopathic master’s degree, traveling there for weeks at a time, and along the way I had the great privilege of eating truly exceptional pizza — the kind that quietly resets your understanding of what pizza can be. I had grown up loving pizza in America, but what I discovered in Italy was something altogether different.
And even in Italy, pizza is not simply pizza.
Travel from one region to another and the crust itself can change. Roman pizza can be thin and crisp. Other Italian traditions produce thicker or more bread-like pizzas. But Naples is famous for something I particularly love: that wonderfully inflated outer rim, the cornicione, filled with irregular pockets of air surrounding a softer, thinner center.
That crust is half the experience for me.
When a beautifully fermented Neapolitan-style dough hits intense heat, the rim seems to come alive. It swells almost before your eyes, blistering and ballooning into these enormous pockets of air. I still get excited watching it happen through the oven door. You can already imagine biting through that crisp, blistered exterior into the soft, airy interior.
It is bread and pizza at the same time.
And then there is American pizza, which became its own collection of traditions. New York pizza is wonderful in an entirely different way — broad, thinner slices with a crisp yet flexible crust made for folding and eating with your hands. Chicago deep-dish goes almost to the opposite extreme: substantial, deeply baked and almost casserole-like, with a thick crust carrying generous layers of sauce and toppings.
I love that about pizza. There isn’t really one pizza.
There are families of pizza, shaped by place, people, ovens, ingredients, and tradition.
When I was in Italy, being vegan often meant ordering mine without cheese. Instead, I might have arugula — rocket, as it’s called there — mushrooms, fresh tomatoes, or simply tomato sauce and vegetables. What surprised me was how little I missed having a mountain of cheese on top. When the dough is that good, you don’t need much.
The crust carries the experience.
That lesson followed me home.
Over time, I found my own way back to the pizzas I remembered by making a long-fermented sourdough dough and keeping the toppings deliberately simple. A light layer of tomato sauce. Beautiful fresh tomatoes when I have them. Spoonfuls of my homemade ricotta. Sometimes a little vegan mozzarella. Fresh basil. Good olive oil.
That’s enough.
In America, pizza seems to occupy two completely different worlds. At one extreme is highly processed fast-food pizza, something we have almost come to think of as the definition of junk food. At the other is an entire world of artisan bakers obsessing over flour, fermentation, hydration, ovens, tomatoes, and the mysterious behavior of dough.
I definitely belong to the second group.
Especially as a sourdough baker, I love that making great pizza requires both knowledge and restraint. The dough itself is extraordinarily simple: flour, water, sourdough starter, and salt. There isn’t much there to hide behind. What transforms those few ingredients is fermentation and time.
My dough rests for 24, 48, sometimes 72 hours. It slowly develops flavor and structure while I do essentially nothing at all.
Then I top it with foods that still look like themselves — tomatoes, basil, olive oil, homemade ricotta. For me, that’s an entirely different way of thinking about pizza. It feels like beautiful bread made into a meal.
Learning to work with a very high-hydration pizza dough did take some practice. Wet dough can seem impossible when you first meet it. It sticks to everything. It spreads. It refuses to behave the way you think dough ought to behave.
And then one day you understand it.
You stop fighting it.
You learn to fold instead of knead, to use wet hands rather than more flour, and most importantly, to preserve all that beautiful air the fermentation worked so hard to create. Once you understand that, I actually think this pizza is easier than making a loaf of artisan sourdough bread.
And there is something wonderfully convenient hiding inside all of that slow fermentation. I can make the dough, divide it into balls, put them in the refrigerator, and suddenly I have the beginnings of several beautiful meals waiting for me over the next few days.
One pizza for us. One to share. One waiting for tomorrow.
Take out a dough ball, let it relax, crush a few tomatoes, gather whatever beautiful toppings are around, and dinner can become something extraordinary with surprisingly little effort.
Maybe that’s part of why I love this pizza so much. It contains two things that might seem contradictory: patience and ease.
You give it time when you have time, and later it gives some of that time back to you.
And when I pull one from the oven, scatter fresh basil across the top and drizzle it with olive oil, I am never entirely standing in my own kitchen anymore.
For just a moment, I’m back in Italy.
I’m walking toward a little pizzeria, excited to sit down and order an authentic pizza. I’m remembering those extraordinary days when eating pizza in Italy wasn’t something I was dreaming about doing someday.
I was actually there.
Maybe that’s why I could eat this pizza at almost any hour — dinner, lunch, even breakfast the next morning. It’s delicious, certainly. But food is rarely only about taste.
Sometimes a crust filled with air, a ripe tomato, a few leaves of basil, and a drizzle of olive oil can carry you thousands of miles.
And sometimes, if you’re lucky, bread doesn’t just hold you together. It carries you home.
INGREDIENTS
For the Sourdough Pizza Dough
320 g bread flour (Bob’s Red Mill Artisan Bread Flour)
80 g 00 flour
320 g water (or 290 g for an easier-to-handle dough; see Notes)
80 g active sourdough starter, at peak (100% hydration)
11 g fine sea salt
For the Simple Tomato Sauce
1½ cups good-quality whole peeled tomatoes, preferably Italian, with enough of their juices to make a loose sauce
Fine sea salt, to taste
For the Toppings
Fresh garden or farmers market tomatoes, thinly sliced
Vegan ricotta, spooned in generous pieces
Vegan mozzarella, lightly scattered, optional
Extra-virgin olive oil
Fine sea salt, to taste
Fresh basil leaves, for finishing
METHOD
DAY 1 — DOUGH DAY
Step 1 — Mix the Dough
Combine in the bowl of a stand mixer:
320 g bread flour
80 g 00 flour
320 g water (or 290 g for the easier-to-handle option)
80 g active sourdough starter, at peak
11 g fine sea salt
Mix briefly on low speed until no dry flour remains and a loose, shaggy dough forms.
Cover and let the dough rest for 20–30 minutes. This short rest allows the flour to hydrate and makes the wet dough easier to strengthen.
Develop the Dough
Mix again on low speed for 2–4 minutes, until the dough becomes more cohesive and begins to develop some strength. It should look smoother than it did after the initial mix, but it will still be very soft, wet, and sticky, especially when using the full 320 g water.
Avoid adding additional flour to make the dough easier to handle. Much of its strength and elasticity will develop through folding and fermentation.
Step 2 — Build Strength
Leave the dough in the mixing bowl and perform 1 set of stretch and folds. Cover and let rest for about 30 minutes.
Transfer the dough to a lightly oiled, shallow container. A clear glass baking dish, approximately 8 × 8 inches, works especially well. Its wide, flat shape makes coil folds easy to perform, while the clear sides make it easier to watch the dough develop bubbles and increase in volume.
If you don’t have a glass dish, simply leave the dough in the mixing bowl and perform the folds there.
Perform 1 coil fold, then cover and rest for approximately 30 minutes.
Check the dough. If it still feels very loose and spreads quickly, perform a second coil fold. As strength develops, the dough should lift more cleanly from the container and settle into a softly rounded shape with gently curved edges. It may gradually relax outward again, but it should no longer immediately flow toward the edges of the container.
Once the dough feels cohesive, elastic, and able to hold itself together, stop folding and allow fermentation to continue undisturbed.
Step 3 — Bulk Ferment
Cover and allow the dough to continue fermenting at room temperature until it is very airy, filled with bubbles, and approximately doubled in size.
The dough should look visibly inflated and feel light and alive, with bubbles appearing along the sides and surface. Give it the time it needs to become fully aerated before dividing and shaping.
Fermentation time will vary depending on the strength of your starter and the temperature of your kitchen, so let the dough rather than the clock tell you when it is ready.
Step 4 — Divide, Shape & Cold Ferment
Gently turn the dough onto a lightly floured work surface and divide it into 3 equal portions, about 270 g each.
Gently shape each portion into a round dough ball, creating enough surface tension to hold its shape without aggressively pressing out the air developed during fermentation.
Lightly oil three individual covered food-storage containers, glass or plastic, approximately 1½–2 quarts each. Place one dough ball into each container, leaving enough room for the dough to relax and expand.
Cover and refrigerate for 24–72 hours.
The long, cold fermentation develops flavor and allows the dough to relax, making it beautifully extensible when it’s time to shape the pizzas.
DAY 2 — BAKE DAY
Step 5 — Make the Simple Tomato Sauce
Place the whole peeled tomatoes and enough of their juices to make a loose sauce in a bowl.
Crush the tomatoes thoroughly with your hands for a rustic texture, or pulse briefly with an immersion blender for a smoother sauce.
Season simply with fine sea salt to taste.
Set aside until ready to assemble the pizzas.
Step 6 — PREPARE FOR BAKING
Heat the Pizza Steel
Place a pizza steel in the oven and preheat the oven to its highest setting, ideally 500–550°F. Allow the steel to heat thoroughly for at least 45–60 minutes before baking.
Remove the dough containers from the refrigerator approximately 1–2 hours before baking. Keep them covered while the dough warms and relaxes.
Prepare the Fresh Tomatoes
Thinly slice the fresh tomatoes.
If they are especially juicy, sprinkle them very lightly with salt and arrange them on a clean kitchen towel or paper towels for 10–15 minutes. This draws away some of the excess moisture and helps prevent a watery pizza.
Have the sauce and all of your remaining toppings ready before shaping the first pizza.
Step 7 — Shape the Pizza
Generously dust a sheet of parchment paper with semolina flour.
Gently turn one relaxed dough ball onto the semolina.
Using your fingertips, press outward from the center, gently encouraging the air toward the perimeter while leaving approximately a ¾–1-inch rim untouched.
Continue opening the dough gently with your fingertips and hands until it reaches approximately 10–12 inches, taking care not to deflate the airy outer rim.
Do not use a rolling pin. The air preserved around the perimeter is what creates the beautifully risen, open crust.
Leave the shaped pizza on the parchment while adding the toppings.
Step 8 — Top & Bake
Spread a thin layer of crushed tomato sauce over the center of the dough, leaving the raised rim uncovered.
Arrange over the pizza:
Thinly sliced fresh tomatoes
Generous spoonfuls of vegan ricotta
A light scattering of vegan mozzarella, if using
Finish with a small drizzle of extra-virgin olive oil and a light sprinkle of fine sea salt.
Using a pizza peel, transfer the pizza with the parchment underneath it directly onto the thoroughly heated pizza steel.
Bake until the crust is deeply golden and blistered, the rim is dramatically risen and airy, and the underside is crisp and well browned, approximately 6–10 minutes, depending on the temperature and character of your oven.
If the underside is ready before the top has developed enough color, finish briefly under the broiler, watching carefully.
Step 9 — Finish & Serve
Remove the pizza from the oven and immediately finish with:
Fresh basil leaves
A drizzle of good extra-virgin olive oil
Let the pizza settle for about a minute.
For easy serving, use clean kitchen scissors to cut the pizza into slices. Scissors work especially well with a light, airy sourdough crust and make it easy to cut cleanly without dragging the toppings across the pizza.
Serve immediately while the crust is still hot and crisp.
Repeat with the remaining dough balls.
NOTES
Hydration
This is an intentionally high-hydration pizza dough. The full 320 g water creates the open interior, delicate chew, and dramatically puffed rim that give this crust its character.
If you are new to very wet doughs, begin with 290 g water. It will be noticeably easier to mix, fold, and shape while still producing a beautifully light crust. Once that feels comfortable, try the full 320 g and let the dough get a little wild. The extra water is part of what makes those wonderful pockets of air possible.
Read the Dough, Not the Clock
Allow the bulk fermentation to continue until the dough is approximately doubled in size, visibly aerated, and filled with bubbles. This full, lively fermentation is important to the character of the finished crust.
How long that takes will depend on your starter, dough temperature, room temperature, and even the season. Don’t rush it simply because a certain number of hours has passed. When the dough looks inflated, feels light, and seems almost alive with air, it is ready to divide.
Mixing by Hand
A stand mixer is convenient, but absolutely not necessary.
Combine the ingredients by hand until no dry flour remains, then allow the dough to rest as directed. After the rest, use a wet hand to squeeze, fold, and work the dough in the bowl for several minutes until it becomes more cohesive.
Don’t worry about making it perfectly smooth. The stretch-and-fold, coil fold, and fermentation will continue developing strength for you.
Folding & Optional Lamination
This dough doesn’t need a complicated folding schedule. One stretch-and-fold followed by a coil fold may be all it needs. If it still spreads quickly and feels weak, give it another coil fold after it has rested.
If you’re experienced with high-hydration bread dough, you can laminate the dough after the first stretch-and-fold, then follow with one or two coil folds as needed.
Either way, stop once the dough is strong enough to hold a softly rounded shape for a while after folding. More folding isn’t necessarily better. Once the structure is there, let fermentation do the work.
Cold Fermentation
After bulk fermentation, divide the dough into 3 portions of approximately 270 g each, shape them into balls, and refrigerate them individually for 24–72 hours.
You don’t need a professional pizza proofing box. Covered 1½–2-quart food-storage containers, glass or plastic, give each dough ball plenty of room to relax and expand.
Balling the dough before refrigeration also makes bake day wonderfully simple: take out the number of dough balls you need, let them warm and relax, and you’re ready to make pizza.
Handling the Dough
High-hydration dough rewards gentle hands. Don’t try to tame its stickiness by kneading additional flour into it.
When shaping, press gently from the center outward and leave approximately ¾–1 inch around the perimeter untouched. That air-filled outer edge becomes the wonderfully puffed cornicione — the raised rim — during baking.
If the dough keeps springing back rather than stretching easily, don’t fight it. Cover it and give it another 10–15 minutes to relax, then continue.
The Simplest Tomato Sauce
For this pizza, I prefer good whole peeled tomatoes crushed by hand or briefly blended with an immersion blender and seasoned simply with salt. That’s all they need.
If you don’t have whole peeled tomatoes, a good plain canned tomato sauce works too. I sometimes warm it briefly with salt and the tiniest pinch of oregano. Keep the seasoning restrained so the tomato remains the flavor you taste.
Cheese & Toppings
I prefer generous little spoonfuls of vegan ricotta and only a light scattering of vegan mozzarella, if I use mozzarella at all. A beautiful fresh-style vegan mozzarella is wonderful when you can find or make one.
Fresh garden or farmers market tomatoes are especially lovely here, but whatever you choose, keep the toppings relatively light. Too much sauce, cheese, or too many toppings can weigh down this delicate, high-hydration crust and make the center harder to bake through.
Let the crust remain part of the experience rather than simply something underneath the toppings. Add fresh basil after baking so it stays fragrant, green, and beautiful.
Parchment & Semolina
I like shaping and building each pizza on parchment dusted with semolina. The parchment makes transferring a very soft dough onto the steel much easier and catches much of the loose semolina that would otherwise scatter into the oven.
It isn’t the traditional method, but in a home kitchen it is wonderfully practical — and makes cleanup much easier.
Baking on a Pizza Steel
A thoroughly heated pizza steel is one of the best ways to create dramatic oven spring in a home oven. Preheat the oven to its highest setting, ideally 500–550°F, and give the steel at least 45–60 minutes to become thoroughly saturated with heat.
Every oven behaves differently, so use the baking time as a guide rather than a rule. The pizza is ready when the rim has risen dramatically and developed deep golden blistering and the underside is crisp and well browned.
If your oven can safely reach temperatures higher than 550°F, the pizza may bake considerably faster, so stay close and watch the crust rather than the clock.
Cutting with Scissors
One of my favorite little pizza tricks is also one of the simplest: cut it with kitchen scissors.
A good pair of clean kitchen scissors moves easily through the airy sourdough rim and crisp base without pressing down on the crust or dragging all those beautiful tomatoes and spoonfuls of ricotta across the pizza. Once you try it, you may never reach for the pizza wheel again.
A Final Thought
The pizzas I remember most from Naples weren’t memorable because they were complicated. They were memorable because everything that was there mattered — the dough, the tomatoes, the olive oil, the basil, and the hands that brought them together.
That’s what I want from this pizza too.
Give the dough time. Let the tomatoes taste like tomatoes. Use the cheese lightly. Scatter on the basil while the pizza is still warm, drizzle over a little good olive oil, and bring it straight to the table.
This is Bread That Holds You Together in one of its happiest forms: bread made slowly, topped simply, cut into pieces, passed around, and eaten while everyone is still reaching for another slice.
.
This is the kind of food that nourishes quietly.
It asks us to slow down,
to listen,
and to remember what is enough.